Browse using the new Vinous website now. Launch →
Printed by, and for the sole use of . All rights reserved © 2015 Vinous Media
Victory from the Jaws of Defeat: 2022 Brunello di Montalcino
BY ERIC GUIDO | NOVEMBER 19, 2026
The stakes are high in Montalcino. It’s a region that proved itself to the world in a relatively short time, only gaining widespread recognition in the 1970s. Brunello di Montalcino is America’s favorite Italian wine, used to celebrate notable events and sipped across tables during business dinners. These are the wines that earned a reputation as the pinnacle of quality Sangiovese in Tuscany, standing proudly as monovarietal interpretations of terroir.
However, Montalcino also faces challenges. Recent growing seasons have been quite difficult. Climate change continues to be a long-term threat. Producers in many nearby appellations have responded with greater speed and organization than those in Montalcino, much of which stems from the importance placed on tradition. For example, I believe many Brunellos spend too much time in wood, which can dry out the wines. Chianti Classico’s Gran Selezione and Montepulciano’s Pieves, while not perfect, have resulted in a pronounced improvement of quality in both of those regions. Winemakers in Montalcino are proud people and, like respected elders, can sometimes need a bit of gentle coaxing to realize that change is necessary. And so, over the last decade, Montalcino has been playing catch-up.

Valdicava's Montosoli vineyard, facing south toward the town of Montalcino.
Today there’s a new energy in Montalcino, a broad realization of the stakes at hand and a concerted effort to course correct. All of this comes at just the right time, as the name of the game has changed. It’s no longer just about heat, drought, frost or disease; it’s about a chaotic mix of every challenge Mother Nature can present, and adapting practices year by year to confront an entirely new paradigm. There’s a silver lining here: producers in Montalcino have stepped up their game in a major way, finding balance amidst even the most difficult seasons. There’s no better example of this than the 2022 vintage.
The Era of Drought: 2019-2022
As I tasted through the 2022 Brunellos in Montalcino this past October, I could not help but think the vintage represents the end of a drought cycle that started in 2019. Over the last few years, I believed the conditions between 2019 and 2022 were representative of a new normal in which any combination of drought and heat would dictate every future growing season. I also feared it would only get worse. While 2019 delivered a stunning selection of wines due to timely late-season rains and the cool temperatures that followed, each of the ensuing years — 2020, 2021 and 2022 — felt increasingly challenging and chaotic.

Thriving in the extreme southeast of Montalcino at Argiano.
Years ago, I stood in the cellar at Poggio di Sotto with Winemaker Leonardo Berti, tasting the just-fermented 2022 wines alongside the 2021 and 2020 Brunellos from barrel. As I tasted, I attempted to decipher which of these vintages would strike the best balance and what character each would eventually assume. The wines were all rich, potent and structured, with varying degrees of elegance, lift or energy. I questioned what the future of Montalcino would look like if vintages continued down this path. That was just before 2023, when the drought era ended with a massive amount of rain through the spring.
2020
The 2020s turned out to be inconsistent, fruit-driven wines, marked by a contrast between edgy tannins (which benefited from gentler maceration and less time in oak) and overly sweet tannins that quickly became fatiguing. It was a year where subzones would have been tremendously useful for consumers, as areas like the southeast enjoyed an extended harvest season while many other sectors suffered. The 2020 Riservas only emphasized the point. While there were many overachievers, across the broader spectrum, extended time in wood only dried out the fruit.

The Giodo vineyard in southern Montalcino looking out toward Mount Amiata.
2021
Tasting the bottled 2021s felt like a breath of fresh air. The season presented minor consistency issues due to a severe April frost that left many producers dependent on secondary buds, but the overall balance across the region was clear. While extremely dry, 2021 was also cooler, with only a few brief heat spikes in the summer. The wines express pure energy, vibrant fruit and rich yet lively textures, offering a jovial feel framed by sweet, crunchy tannins. The 2021s were an undeniable success, though the picture is more nuanced with 2021 Riservas, which I will address later in this report.
2022
I vividly recall my time in Montalcino in July 2022. Fear was circulating around the entire region. It hadn’t rained since April, and, worse still, there had been little rain or snow during the prior winter months. With no water reserves in the soils and no rain for nearly 90 days, the vineyards were severely stressed. Clay soils dried out as large fissures formed, releasing whatever moisture they had held. Cover crops were nearly nonexistent, and the landscape resembled a desert where only succulents thrived. To make matters worse, Montalcino endured multiple heat waves in June and July, pushing temperatures as high as 104° Fahrenheit. Just two weeks into July, veraison had already begun. Winemaker Pietro Riccobono of Val di Suga said at the time, “Sangiovese can adapt to heat, but it needs water.”

Looking east toward Val d'Orcia at Fuligni.
A downpour drenched the area on the evening of July 29. I spoke with several producers in Montalcino the following morning, only to realize the rain had been frustratingly localized. Jan Hendrik Erbach of Pian dell’Orino explained that he received just a few millimeters in some vineyards, a deluge in another location and zero precipitation in others. It was far from what the region needed to recover, but it provided many winemakers with a glimmer of hope.
It wasn’t until early August that the 2022 vintage began to turn around in a meaningful way. Precipitation totaled 75-85 millimeters by the middle of the month, but the earlier damage to the fruit was largely irreversible. September continued with cooler temperatures and more rain. The winemaking challenge in 2022 was striking a balance between sugar levels and the seeds' physiological ripeness by the time of harvest. Many producers picked early, while others held out as long as possible. Strict selection was paramount, which, coupled with already shrunken berries, resulted in lower yields.

The dramatic exposition of La Magia's vineyards facing Mount Amiata.
The Wines
There is remarkably higher consistency across most classic (annata) Brunello di Montalcino bottlings versus the “Selezione” or single-vineyard wines (Vigna). That’s not to say the single-vineyard wines I encountered aren’t balanced, but those that are typically more concentrated or powerful can at times come across as clumsy or simply too much of everything, resulting in an experience that starts out pleasurable yet becomes cloying over time. Wines that are a blend from multiple sites fared better and show more balance. This is very much a vintage that depended on intervention. While winemakers in the region’s southwest reported far worse conditions than those in the northeast, success ultimately came down to wineries willing to sacrifice yields or adapt cellar practices. Cooler fermentations to avoid harsher phenolic compounds, shorter macerations to offset aggressive, astringent seed tannins, gentle pumpovers, less time in wood and less aggressive regimes saved the vintage at many estates. Many producers decided against making a Riserva, instead using that juice to bolster their straight Brunellos.

Husband-and-wife team Angelo Pinti and Angelina Ndreca, masters of northeastern Montalcino terroir at Pian delle Querci.
Overall, the 2022s excel through their contrast of potency and grace, often bringing the word “buoyancy” to mind. They seem to envelop the palate while maintaining finesse and energy. Across the spectrum, the wines show more blue fruit and floral tones than usual. Immediacy is a hallmark, but the wines also possess the balance to carry well through the medium term. Readers who are willing to set aside the notion that all young Brunello must be austere and aggressively tannic will find much to love in 2022. It’s a year of elegance, without the fatiguing combination of acid and alcohol that burdened so many 2020s.
The 2022s rank above the 2020s in both quality and character, but slightly lower than the 2021s. The entry-level wines and estate blends are the most surprising overperformers in 2022, wines I consistently found myself scoring higher than usual. Though the peaks don't quite reach the heights of years like 2019 or 2021, 2022 is a remarkably successful vintage where producers snatched victory from the jaws of defeat.

Siro Pacenti discussing winemaking in Montalcino's deep south in the Piancornello vineyard.
The Racy 2021 Riservas
It’s always instructive to taste wines from two distinctly different vintages side by side. In the case of 2022 and 2021, both have generous fruit profiles, but the 2021s have notably more structure and acidity, juxtaposed against the more floral 2022s. While a few more years in bottle will certainly bring more harmony, the finest 2021 Brunellos are already showing well.

The town of Montalcino from Le Chuise in the northeast.
When it comes to the 2021 Riservas, the highs are very high, but the lows are also very low. The best 2021 Riservas marry their racy, radiant character with concentrated fruit and sweet tannins that frame the wine rather than restrain it. They are structured yet never drying, guided by the innate energy of the 2021 growing season. Some of these wines are truly revelatory, but in most cases, I do not believe these will be 20-year wines. Only at the very top do I find that level of balance. I expect the good-to-very-good 2021 Riservas will perform best over a 10- to 15-year window. However, I also believe that this is the new reality for a good vintage in Montalcino, and I ask: is there anything wrong with that?

Looking west across from their new high-elevation vineyards at Le Potazzine.
Then there’s the flip side of the 2021 Riservas. I can’t recall ever tasting of a single category and vintage where the highs and lows are so polarized. In many cases, the 2021 Riservas are simple, fun wines that drink far too easily. There’s nothing wrong with a fun wine, but when it comes at the premium price many Brunello Riservas do, it gives me pause. If a Riserva lands in at the same quality as an annata — or, dare I say, a Rosso — I must question its reason for existing.
Additionally, some producers impeded the vintage-2021 radiance with aggressive oak regimes or forced concentration. In those instances, the wines come across as painfully out of balance. The Riserva category should be reserved exclusively for favorable vintages. What's more, in a warm or excessively dry year, extended time in wood rarely helps the wines. The regulations for the Riserva category allow producers to bottle after only two years in wood, exactly like a standard Brunello; the wine must then simply be held in bottle for an additional year before release (an approach that some, like Canalicchio di Sopra, adopted years ago to great success). Extended élevage for Riservas is a choice rather than a mandate.

Tenuta Luce vineyards in the southwest of Montalcino.
I tasted the wines for this article in Montalcino, through producer visits in July 2026 and organized tastings at the Consorzio del Vino Brunello di Montalcino in October 2026.
© 2026, Vinous. No portion of this article may be copied, shared or redistributed without prior consent from Vinous. Doing so is not only a violation of our copyright but also threatens the survival of independent wine criticism.
You Might Also Enjoy
The Exquisite 2021 Brunellos, Eric Guido, November 2025
A Tale of Two Extremes: The 2020 Brunellos and 2019 Riservas, Eric Guido, November 2024
The Magic of 2022 Rosso di Montalcino, Eric Guido, September 2024
Buckle Your Seatbelts: 2019 Brunello and 2021 Rosso di Montalcino, Eric Guido, December 2023
The Rise of Rosso di Montalcino, Eric Guido, October 2022
Show all the wines (sorted by score)
- Altesino
- Ambrogio e Giovanni Folonari Tenute - Tenuta La Fuga
- Aminta - Famiglia Cecchi
- Antinori - Pian delle Vigne
- Argiano
- Armilla
- Banfi
- Baricci
- Biondi-Santi Tenuta Greppo
- Camigliano
- Campogiovanni
- Canalicchio di Sopra
- Canneta
- Capanna
- Caparzo
- Caprili
- Carpineto
- Casanova delle Cerbaie
- Casanova di Neri
- Casisano
- Castello Finoto
- Castello Giulio
- Castello Romitorio
- Castello Tricerchi
- Castiglion del Bosco
- Cava d'Onice
- Ciacci Piccolomini d'Aragona
- Claudia Ferrero
- Col d'Orcia
- Collemattoni
- Collosorbo
- Conti Marone Cinzano
- Cortonesi
- Costanti
- Croce di Mezzo
- Cupano
- Donatella Cinelli Colombini
- Donna Olga
- Fanti
- Fattoi
- Fattoria di Barbi
- Franco Pacenti
- Fuligni
- Gianni Brunelli - Le Chiuse di Sotto
- Giodo
- Il Marroneto
- Il Palazzone
- Il Poggione
- Il Valentiano di Ciacci Fabiano
- Innocenti
- La Casaccia di Franceschi
- La Fiorita
- La Gerla
- La Magia
- Lambardi
- La Poderina
- La Serena
- La Torre
- Lazzeretti
- Le Chiuse
- Le Macioche Famiglia Cotarella
- Le Potazzine
- Le Ragnaie
- Lisini
- Luciani
- Marchesi Frescobaldi
- Mastrojanni
- Máté
- Mocali
- Molino di Sant'Antimo
- Padelletti
- Palazzo
- Patrizia Cencioni
- Piancornello
- Pian delle Querci
- Pian delle Querci - Serbolino
- Pian dell'Orino
- Piccini
- Pietroso
- Pieve Santa Restituta
- Pinino
- Podera Giardino
- Podere Brizio
- Podere La Vigna
- Podere Le Ripi
- Podere San Giacomo
- Podere Scopetone
- Poggio alle Forche
- Poggio di Sotto
- Poggio Landi
- Poggio Nardone
- Ridolfi
- Ruffino
- Salicutti
- Salvioni
- Sancarlo
- San Lorenzo
- San Polo
- Santa Giulia
- Sassetti Livio Pertimali
- Sasso di Luna
- Sasso di Sole
- Scopone
- Sesta di Sopra
- Sesti - Castello di Argiano
- Siro Pacenti
- Soldera
- Stella di Campalto
- Talenti
- Tassi
- Tenuta di Sesta
- Tenuta Luce
- Tenuta Poggio Il Castellare
- Tenuta San Giorgio
- Tenute Donna
- Tenute Silvio Nardi
- Tiezzi
- Uccelliera
- Valdicava
- Val di Suga
- Villa al Cortile
- Villa Poggio Salvi
- Voliero